The Screen Game: A Missing Piece for the Bears’ Offense?

Brad Biggs at the Chicago Tribune has 10 thoughts after the Bears preseason game against the Browns.  

10b. It was interesting to hear Ben Johnson go into fine details of the screen game, something that has been a major focus for the offense in training camp practices. Salvon Ahmed scored a touchdown on one, but as Johnson noted, there’s so much that goes into a productive or explosive screen.

“We’ve been harping on those details,” he said. “We’ve got specific landmarks. We drill them every single day. I think our defense has done a really good job throughout the week of practice to make those hard for us. So, we’ve had a lot of very difficult looks. Some of our worst plays in practice over the last couple weeks have been our screens.

“I just think it’s a really good job up front, executing the timing, the rhythm, and then we always talk about those screen runners when they get the ball in the hands. We’re trying to get vertical for a few steps and then it turns into a punt return after that. That’s certainly what that one looked like as he was taking it across the field. So, good to see those guys blocking down the field. A guy like (receiver) Kaden Davis, who really is trying to run coverage away from the screen, ends up making a key block, and it’s good to see things like that.”

I addressed Ahmed and his uphill battle to win the third running back position battle in a previous post.

I was glad to read that the Bears have been working on their screen game.  

As I emphasized in a previous post, the Bears won only 2 games within the division last year. And one of those was a miracle, once-in-a-generation comeback against the Packers. A big reason for tha tis the Bears scored an average of 20.5 points per game against division opponents Vs. 28.9 overall against the league. They need to work on the offense to add dimensions to their game to make it harder for teams that know them well to stop them.

The screen play can be a devastating weapon for a team that can execute it well. While the league average for screen plays generally hovers just under 5 yards per play, teams like the Lions, Buccaneers, and Cardinals have all averaged at least 6.5 yards per play and 0.2 Expected Points Added (EPA) per play on screen passes.  I can remember some seasons where the Packers repeatedly absolutely killed opponents with well timed screens.

Furthermore, screens have a high floor compared to traditional dropbacks. Offenses can generally mitigate negative plays while still maintaining a higher explosive play rate than standard designed runs.  It also, obviously  effectively neutralizes the pass rush.

If the Bears can get this play right, it can be a very effective antidote for a lot of things that aggressive defenses like the Vikings try to do.  In addition, as Johnson tries to push the ball downfield, the screen can add a short field counter punch if defenses are leaving an excessive amount of space underneath in response.  It adds an extra dimension to the offense and will be one more thing that teams have to worry about.

Posted in Chicago Bears | Leave a comment

Salvon Ahmed and the Battle for the Bears’ Third Running Back Spot

Salvon Ahmed.

Brad Biggs at the Chicago Tribune has 10 thoughts after the Bears preseason game against the Browns.  At one point he addresses the competition for the thirrd running back position:

An interesting option is Salvon Ahmed, a 27-year-old who played previously for Studesville in Miami and missed all last season after suffering an ankle injury on a hip-drop tackle in an Indianapolis Colts practice.

Ahmed got two carries — one for 15 yards and another for 2 — and caught three passes for 55 yards, scooting 49 yards for a touchdown on a screen from Case Keenum at the start of the third quarter.

“We feel good about those top two backs right now and where they’re at,” Ben Johnson said. “So, the battle for three, four, five, whatever that looks like, a lot comes down to special teams. A lot comes down to how do you separate yourself from those top two guys? What’s your skill set? How’s it different?

“(Ahmed) has got that slashing mentality where he’s hard to bring down in space, and that showed up again today. Showed up in practice really throughout camp so far. We’ll continue to challenge him to find a defined role there on special teams where he can help us out the most there. And then pass protection, how do we continue to improve? When you’re a little bit smaller as a running back, that’s always what I’m looking for. How well, how stout are we holding up to a blitzing linebacker?”

At 5-foot-11 and 197 pounds, Ahmed has a good feel for a lot of the outside-zone concepts because they mirror what he did with the Dolphins. The third running back is usually a main cog on special teams. Ahmed got 38 snaps on special teams for the Dolphins in 2022 and 70 in 2023. Conversely, Roschon Johnson has logged 386 snaps on special teams over the previous three seasons.

Ahmed might give the Bears a little more juice on offense, as he showed while sprinting to the end zone, but if the top two backs are healthy and rolling, is Roschon Johnson a better fit in the overall picture when it comes to the 53-man roster?

It’s one of the questions the team needs to sort through in the coming weeks. They have to challenge Ahmed and see what he can do on special teams. With some good fortune, the offense won’t have to lean on the third back to carry a significant load during the regular season.

That was a long quite but there’s a lot in it to unpack.  I’m really glad that Biggs brought Ahmed up.  I was hearing alot about his performances in camp and I was looking forward to seeing him.  And I wasn’t diasppointed.  Like many of the teams’ fans I’m sure, he cuaght my eye during the game, epsecially when you contrasted him with Johnson, who had a pedestrian performance.

First, I’ll get back to the screen play in another post but its worth noting that one of Ahmed’s particular skills is pass catching.  When he was with the Dolphins he was often prasied for his speed and route running ability.  That’s going to be important to Ben Johnson, espcially if Ahmed is significantly better at it than D’Andre Swift and Kyle Monangai.

Second, it probably isn’t a coincidence that Ben Johnson brought up pass protection. Ahmed’s lack of size can be a disadvantage when matching up against blitzing linebackers. In the past, coaches have consistently noted that he needs to improve his effort and stoutness in pass protection and he’s had a hard time in the past earning significant playing time on third downs.

But its those special teams stats that BIggs cited are really going to hurt Ahmed.  With his speed, you would think that earning time no special teams should be sonething he could do,  But there’s a reason that he hasn’t played more in that phase in the past.  He needs to imporve in that area.

As impressed with Ahmed as I was with what I saw, I’m definitely pumping the brakes on him.  He might be destined for the practice squad with Johnson sticking in the third running back spot for his special teams play.  This would allow them to bring Ahmed back onto the 53 man roster if there is a rash of injuries and the services of a dynamic back on the offense are required.

Posted in Chicago Bears, Cleveland Browns | Leave a comment

Mediocre at Best: Browns QB Concerns Continue Against Bears

Charean Williams at profootballtalk.com on Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson’s play yesterday:

Browns coach Todd Monken said it was “cool” and “awesome” to watch Deshaun Watson play on Saturday. It was Watson’s first game of any kind since Oct. 20, 2024.

The quarterback, who is competing with Shedeur Sanders for the starting job, was 11-of-15 for 126 yards and lost a fumble in the first half. The Browns scored 10 points while Watson was in the game [for the first half].

He may have won the starting job.

I kind of doubt that.  Neither Browns quarterback looked all that good to me.  Watson didn’t throw a single deep pass.  This may have been in part because he was having yet another health an issue, this time with his elbow.

Watson has played only 19 games since the Browns acquired him in a 2022 offseason trade with the Texans. He served an 11-game suspension in 2022, underwent season-ending shoulder surgery in 2023 and twice tore his Achilles, which kept him out 10 games in 2024 and all of 2025.

Watson, who turns 31 in September, said he had no problem with his Achilles. He experienced brief numbness in his forearm during the game.

“It was just my forearm and elbow,” Watson said. “Just a little numbness, but it went away as the game continued to go on. It was just a little funny bone thing.”

Sanders took the positives from the terrible interception that he threw but it was emblematic of his performance.

“What’d I see? The right read, just slipped. It was the right read, it just slipped,” Sanders said. “That’s what makes me mad a little bit. But any decision I make, I know is the right decision, I just didn’t execute the decision, but the right decision was made. So every day I look at my decision making. How’s my decision-making? That’s how I grade myself. Obviously turning the ball over is not great and I won’t survive a long time in the league doing that, but as long as my eyes and my feet and everything were in the right place, being able to execute, it just may happen.”

Sanders didn’t execute consistently and Watson continually settled for the short throw against a mostly vanilla Bears defense.  I would call both quarterbacks mediocre at best under conditions where true NFL starters should have excelled.  

It isn’t the only problem that they have.  But the Browns problems are going to start at quarterback again this year unless one of these players gets a lot better.

Posted in Cleveland Browns | Leave a comment

Ben Johnson’s Wants a Historic Offensive Year. I’m On Board.

Mike Florio on Bears head coach Ben Johnson’s stated goal of being the highest scoring offense of all time.

There’s a certain logic to setting goals higher than the ultimate goal. Still, the only goal that matters most to NFL fans is winning Super Bowls. Scoring doesn’t matter. Winning streaks don’t matter.

The goal is to get to the playoffs and then be the one team that runs the table.

Florio has a point.  But he’s not accounting for the fact that Bears fans have been starved to offensive success for 20 years now.

In 13 of the last 20 seasons, the Bears have ranked 20th or worse in total offensive yards and between 2016 and 2024 the team ranked 20th or worse in scoring offense seven times, bottoming out at 32nd in total yards during the 2024 season.

Even when the Bears have success as a team, it’s almost never because of the offense. During their 2005 playoff run, they managed to win 11 games despite fielding the 29th-ranked offense in total yards and the 26th-ranked scoring unit.

Honestly, Bears games were so misserable to have to watch that I felt the need to apologize to fans of other teams becasue they were forced to watch their offensive incompetance in prime time slots on national television.

It’s been so long since the Bears have had sustained offensive success that they barely remember what a good quarterback looks like.  Before Caleb Williams hit the scene, many Bears fans wouldn’t recognize one is they saw one.

I guess what I’m saying is, yes, team success is the ultimate goal.  But Bears fans are starved for more more and, given the recent history of the franchise, how the team wins is going to count for a lot with them.  

Johnson is playing to the crowd when he sets offensive success as a major priority.  Win or lose, the Bears are finally playing an entertaining brand of football.  Bears fans can appreciate and respond to that perhaps more than fans of any other team in the NFL.

Posted in Chicago Bears | Leave a comment

I’ll Believe That the Bears Will Trade for Vita Vea When I See It

Vita Vea 2021 (cropped).

Mike Garafolo of NFL Media reports that the Bills, 49ers and Bears are among the teams who have called the Bucs about disgruntled defensive tackle Vita Vea.

Vea requested a trade ahead of training camp after spending the offseason seeking a new contract.

I’m calling BS here.

I think that this rumor is simply a result of the fact that people know that the Bears need a defensive tackle. However, I don’t think they’re thinking this through.

I’m sure that defensive coordinator Dennis Allen is looking for defensive tackles. But it became evident in the off-season that he wants tackles that can penetrate. That’s not really what Vea does. He’s a large man that acts as a plug in the middle of the defense.  Think former Bear Andrew Billings, now with the Cardinals.

Don’t get me wrong. Vea is a wonderful player. But I don’t believe that he fits the Bears’ defensive scheme and I’ll believe that the Bears want him when I see them trade for him.

Leave a comment

Accuracy Means More Than the Completion Percentage for Caleb Williams

Caleb Williams (54858668366) (cropped).

From the Bears practice report at the Chicago Tribune:

The most consistent connection of the day was a familiar sight: [Caleb] Williams to [Colston] Loveland. There are more and more plays in which Loveland catches the ball in stride, and that’s leading to yards after the catch, a primary ingredient in explosive plays.

These practice reports from the various media outlets are generally of limited value because they usually highlight flash plays that can’t tell you how a player is truly doing in camp. We have to see these players on the field ourselves before we can make any real judgments about them.

In contrast, this comment from the Tribune was very valuable. There’s much talk about Caleb Williams having a 70% completion rate as a goal this season. However, I would argue that this is secondary to ball placement on the passes that Williams does complete.

Game after game last year, we watched Williams complete passes in situations where the receiver had to stop or otherwise alter their movement to break stride in order to make the catch. The ability to hit players like Loveland in stride this season will be a key to offensive success and it’s one of the things that we can perhaps monitor as we watch Williams play throughout the preseason.

Posted in Chicago Bears | Leave a comment

The Simple Reason Why Ben Johnson Wants Caleb Williams to Complete 70% of His Passes

Brad Biggs at the Chicago Tribune answers your questions:

Your idea of a good completion percentage for Caleb Williams — around 63% — seems way more reasonable than Ben Johnson’s goal of 70%. Most NFL quarterbacks never have one season at 70%. Peyton Manning and Tom Brady never hit 70%, nor have fellow MVPs Patrick Mahomes, Lamar Jackson or Josh Allen. Prehistoric Dan Marino and John Elway hit 60% only four and three times, respectively, in their 17-year Hall of Fame careers. Why do Johnson and a lot of NFL commentators seem so out of touch? Was it wise to put the pressure of an unreasonable goal in the mind of a second-year quarterback? — Damian W., Missoula, Mont.

I think I referenced 63% as what ought to be an attainable mark for Williams in an appearance on the “Mully & Haugh Show” on WSCR-AM 670. Johnson should keep the bar very high for Williams and all of his players because there’s always room for improvement. There’s no question Williams will need to be more accurate this season in terms of completion percentage and ball-placement — putting the ball in a place where the target has the best opportunity for yards after the catch — if the offense is going to take a big jump.

I can tell you why he wants him to hit 70%.  It’s because Jared Goff completed 72.4% of his passes in 2024, his best season in that regard ever the year before Johnson joined the Bears.

This goal is at least as much about Johnson and it is about Williams.  It’s a personal best for him and he wants to take Williams to the point where he can beat it with his own team.  It’s that simple.

Posted in Chicago Bears | Leave a comment

Raiders Cousins – Crosby Fight Must Have Been Out of the Ordinary to Result in Reduced Camp Time

Josh Alper at profootballtalk.com passes along the report that the fight on Friday between Maxx Crosby and Kirk Cousins resulted in a day off for both players on Friday.

“We have very clear expectations on how we want to practice and how we want to go about our business, and we violated that yesterday,” [head coach Klint] Kubiak said, via Ryan McFadden of ESPN.com.

With Cousins out of practice, first overall pick Fernando Mendoza got an extended run with the first team offense during team drills.

I’m a bit surprised that anything came of this.  The reaction on Friday after practice was simply a “that’s training camp” shrug from Kubiak.  Apparently on reflection Kubiak decided it was a bit more than that.

You wonder if this wasn’t simply a way to give both men a day off and an excuse to get Mendoza extra snaps.  He’ll certainly be starting sooner rather than later and will need to be well prepared just to run the offense in the preseason games. 

Still, Kubiak could have done all of that without calling attention to the incident.  You wonder if both players didn’t cross the line in what may have been an extraordinary affair.  I look forward to seeing if there are more comments on the incident from the players involved.

Posted in Oakland Raiders | Leave a comment

The Loss of Safety Coby Bryant is a Big Blow to the Bears Early Season Defensive Hopes

Coby bryant.

The Bears have lost safety Coby Bryant to an eight-to-10 week left knee inury. From the Chicago Tribune:

“Bryant signed a three-year, $40 million contract in free agency with the Bears in March. He won a Super Bowl with the Seattle Seahawks last season.”

“Tight end Colston Loveland was nearby when Bryant exited practice.

“‘It always sucks to see,” Loveland said. ‘That’s always part of (the game), but he’s tough, he’s a dog.’

With Bryant sidelined for the defense, veteran safety Cam Lewis stepped into the starting lineup alongside rookie Dillon Thieneman. Backup Elijah Hicks (shin) has been sidelined since camp started, but he could be another option at safety when he returns. Cornerback Jaylon Jones worked at the nickel with Kyler Gordon (calf) still out.

Bryant was the premier free agent addition to the Bears.  Along with Thieneman the plan was to build an elite defense on the backend to help offset a suspect pass rush.  The new safety lineup would have allowed a lot of versatility schematically.  But now, especially when you add Bryant’s loss to the fact that Gordon has been unable to find his way onto the field, all of that is on hold.

One thing is for sure.  The Bears don’t have a good replacement on hand.  

Hicks has been with the Bears a long time.  He knows his way around the defense.  But he has primarily been a special teamer.  

Lewis was an undrafted free agent with the Bills whose strength is also special teams.  He’s a versatile performer, having played multiple positions across the secondary, including slot cornerback, outside cornerback, and safety.  He was already playing some nickel behind Gordon.  

Though lewis is decent in run support, his coverage is suspect with a 2025 PFF coverage grade of 54.5, ranking 67th among 98 qualified safeties.  His overall PFF defensive grade of 57.5 ranked 77th among qualified safeties.

It wouldn’t be much of an exaggeration to say that Bryant was the player on defense the Bears could least afford to lose.  Debatably, only the loss of Montez Sweat from a shallow pass rush group would have been worse.  Jaylon Johnson is probably their best player but they have more depth at outside corner to back him up.

The best laid plans of mice and men often go awry.  As was the case last year, defensive coordinator Dennis Allen will have his work cut out for him this season as he watches his initial plans already going up in smoke.

Leave a comment

How Will the Bears Increase Caleb Williams Accuracy?

Caleb Williams (54858668366) (cropped).

Michael David Smith at profootballtalk.com quotes head coach Ben Johnson on quarterback Caleb Williams.  Williams is apparently doing what it takes to improve his accuracy.  His completion rate was only 58% last year.

“He’s done a great job over the spring and summer, just looking at himself, body position-wise, from an accuracy standpoint, are my feet aligned to where I want to throw the ball?  The ability to see where I should go with the football, to process a little faster, that’s where I’m hopeful that we see another step in terms of the processing speed.”

I think that last part can’t be emphasized enough.

The head and the arm are connected and how accurate a quarterback is will depend a great deal on how confident he is about where he’s throwing the ball.  Mitch Trubisky came into the NFL with an extrememly accurate arm.  But he never showed that with the Bears because he never got comfortable with reading what was in front of him.

As Williams progresses with his processing speed, everything will slow down.  He’ll be more relaxed about getting himself set and he’ll be able to concentrate more on placing the ball where it needs to be to hit a receiver in stride.  Its notable that Johnson emphasized 

Most of us depend upon video analysis to judge how fast a quarterback is processing what he sees.  This analysis is usually done by a member of the media who doesn’t know exactly what the play call was or exactly where the quarterback is being told to place his eyes.  But I would say you can easily loook at how accurate a quarterback like Williams is and that will tell you a lot about how well they’re seeing the game.

Posted in Chicago Bears | Leave a comment